Pin It

On Oct 3, 2010, at 2:32 PM, Paul Zielinski wrote:

You cannot actually get around this with quasi-local quantities. You have to abandon the classic EP argument that frame
transformations literally cancel first-order geometric distortions of a flat Minkowski geometry in GR.


As you know, I think you are in serious error on this specific point.

You're entitled to your opinion. But if the energy carried by the waves is determined by first-order terms in the expansion of the metric around any given point, then if there is no first-order invariant measure of deviation from Minkowski geometry, we are stuck with a spooky non-local vacuum energy density, which is a serious headache in canonical GR. As we've previously discussed at great length.

Right - but this weird classical nonlocality is accepted by the Pundits. Maybe Hagen Kleinert's math does what you want?

Gravitational energy density is not determined by the Riemann curvature in Einstein's theory. It is determined by purely first order quantities.

Basic problem is that total energy is not well defined in GR except in very special cases when there are timelike Killing vector fields. This corresponds to flat spacetime Noether's theorem where total energy is conserved when there is symmetry under time translations. That is simply not true at all in our actual accelerating expanding universe, for example.

Is Energy Conserved in General Relativity?
In newtonian physics, energy conservation and momentum conservation are two .... We will not delve into definitions of energy in general relativity such as ...
www.phys.ncku.edu.tw/mirrors/.../Relativity/.../energy_gr.html - Cached - Similar
?
Conservation of energy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In general relativity conservation of energy-momentum is expressed with the aid of a stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor. ...
History - The first law of thermodynamics - Mechanics - See also
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservation_of_energy - Cached - Similar
energy conservation in General relativity [Archive] - Physics Forums
7 posts - 5 authors - Last post: Apr 10
[Archive] energy conservation in General relativity Special & General Relativity .
www.physicsforums.com › ... › Special & General Relativity - Cached - Similar
8 A Note on General Relativity, Energy Conservation, and Noether's ...
by K Brading - 2005 - Cited by 4 - Related articles
story of the status of energy conservation in General Relativity, concerning two related claims made by Klein and Hilbert: that the energy conservation law ...
www.springerlink.com/index/rv2n078811344m45.pdf - Similar
Energy conservation and equivalence principle in General ...
by MB Mensky - 2004 - Cited by 3 - Related articles
A covariant integral form of the conservation law for the energy–momentum of matter is then derived in General Relativity. ...
linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0375960104008527 - Similar
[gr-qc/0409121] Energy conservation and equivalence principle in ...
by MB Mensky - 2004 - Cited by 3 - Related articles
Sep 30, 2004 ... A covariant integral form of the conservation law for the energy-momentum of matter is then derived in General Relativity. ...
arxiv.org › gr-qc - Cached
Energy Is Not Conserved | Cosmic Variance | Discover Magazine
Feb 22, 2010 ... TimG– No, even that kind of energy conservation is not true. ... “in general relativity spacetime can give energy to matter, ...
blogs.discovermagazine.com/.../02/.../energy-is-not-conserved/ - Cached - Similar
Sean Carroll: Lecture Notes on General Relativity - 11:56am
Try the No-Nonsense Introduction to General Relativity, a 24-page condensation ... energy-momentum tensor -- perfect fluids -- energy-momentum conservation ...
preposterousuniverse.com/grnotes/ - Cached - Similar
Energy Conservation « viXra log
This form of the law of energy conservation in general relativity tells us that the energy from all these contributions plus the gravitational contribution ...
blog.vixra.org/category/energy-conservation/ - Cached
[DOC] General Relativistic Violation of the Conservation of Energy Law
File Format: Microsoft Word - View as HTML
So long as the Killing vector symmetry holds, the energy conservation law is applicable and is not violated, even under general relativity. ...
www.cheniere.org/.../ General%20Relativistic%20Violation%20of%20the%20Conservatio... -Similar

I think everyone who matters in this field now admits that this is a major headache in GR.
 
But the energy carried by the waves is *first* order in the metric.
 
This is different from Hagen-Kleinert's multi-valued maps corresponding to real invariant topological, e.g. disclination defects that are not found in Einstein's 1916 restricted GCTs. What you were looking for Z is in Kleinert's work.

No, what I was looking for is what I found. No need for Kleinert's model to solve the problem. You just have to get over the root misconception that the LC covariant derivative is the only curved-space covariant derivative that can be legitimately defined in GR without altering the underlying intrinsic geometry.

You cannot introduce new connections without justification. It's fine to introduce torsion and non-metricity tensor additions to Levi-Civita only if they explain data anomalies like the Pioneer, flyby etc. Otherwise, ghostly connections without empirical necessity are excess metaphysical baggage in my opinion - they are less with more.