"I wish to thank Martin Rees and John Field for helpful discussions and Timothy Farley and Neville Moray for advice on statistics."
"I suspect this paper is not right. Ptolemy's epicycles fit the data at the time pretty well also. However, I have not had time to read it carefully. I still do not understand the basic picture the author is proposing. However he cites Martin Rees helping him so I am not ready to dismiss it as crank. His model seems to dispense with Einstein's GR hence my bias against it."
-- Jack Sarfatti