Every few months, a headline says AI has proven a theorem or solved a millennium problem in mathematics. Then I hear that physics is next and quantum gravity is cited as what they want to "solve". That's a statement from someone who doesn't understand science. I read these the way I read headlines about string theory, with one eyebrow raised and a cup of coffee in hand.
AI is going to do a lot for physics. It will not settle a question about nature from inside a computer, and neither will a theorist with a pencil. A theorist with a pencil can write down and work out a new idea. AI can make sure that idea does not violate a proven mathematical result and check for consistency with known data. The universe as observed in the lab and in the heavens gets the last word. That's how science works.
Has AI proven the Riemann hypothesis? There is a claim today that it has. A valid proof settles the question inside mathematics, whatever the universe happens to do. We can write down spaces with any number of dimensions, geometries with any curvature, and algebraic structures with no known physical counterpart. Mathematics can describe worlds that look nothing like ours.
Physics has to describe the one we live in. A mathematically consistent theory can describe a perfectly coherent universe that is simply not this one. The graveyard of physics is full of beautiful mathematics that did not survive contact with experiment, and more of it sits in limbo with no known physical relevance. For that reason, solving a mathematical problem tied to quantum gravity does not solve quantum gravity as a physical problem.
To read more, click here.